Dysfunction is Evidence of Our Humanness (Guest Post)

By Dr. Robert F. Mullen 

There is a joke that circulates among mental health professionals. Why do only 26% of people have a diagnosable mental disorder? Because the other 74% haven’t been diagnosed yet.

We are all psychologically dysfunctional in some way. “Mental illnesses are so common that almost everyone will develop at least one diagnosable mental disorder at some point in their life” (Scientific American).

Why do we treat the mentally ill with contempt, trepidation, and ridicule? We are hard-wired to fear and isolate mental illness, and we have been misinformed by history and the disease model of mental health. There are four common misconceptions about psychological dysfunctions. They are (1) abnormal and selective, (2) consequence of behavior, (3) solely mental, and (4) psychotic.

Let us deconstruct these misconceptions, beginning with the latter.

A dysfunctional person is psychotic.

There are two degrees of mental disorder: neuroses and psychoses. When someone sees, hears, or responds to things that are not actual, they are having a psychotic episode. While few persons experience psychosis, everyone has moderate-and-above levels of anxiety, stress, and depression. We are universally neurotic. Since the overwhelming majority of mental disorders are neuroses, we are all dysfunctional to some extent.

A dysfunction is abnormal or selective. 

A neurosis is a condition that negatively impacts our emotional wellbeing and quality of life but does not necessarily impair or interfere with normal day-to-day functions. It is a standard part of natural human development. One-in-four individuals have a diagnosable neurosis. According to the World Health Organization, nearly two-thirds of those reject or refuse to disclose their condition. Including those who dispute or chose to remain oblivious to their dysfunction, we can conclude that mental disorders are common, undiscriminating, and impact us all in some fashion or another. Many of us have more than one disorder; depression and anxiety are commonly comorbid, often accompanied by substance abuse.

A dysfunction is the consequence of a person’s behavior. 

Combined statistics prove that 89% of neuroses onset at adolescence or earlier. In the rare event conditions like PTSD or clinical narcissism manifest later in life, the susceptibility originates in childhood. Most psychologists agree that they are consequence of childhood physical, emotional, or sexual disturbance. Any number of things can cause this. Perhaps parents are controlling or do not provide emotional validation. Maybe the child is subjected to bullying or from a broken home. Behaviors later in life may impact the severity but are not responsible for the neurosis itself. It is not the fault of the child/adolescent, nor reflective of their behavior. There is the likelihood no one is intentionally responsible. This disputes moral models that we are to blame for our disorder, or it is God’s punishment for sin.

A dysfunction is solely mental.

To early civilizations, mental illness was the domain of supernatural forces and demonic possession. Hippocrates and diagnosticians of the 19th century looked at the relative proportions of bodily fluids. Lunar influence, sorcery, and witchcraft are timeless culprits. In the early 20th century, it was somatogenic. The biological approach argues that dysfunction is related to the brain’s physical functioning, while pharmacology promotes it as a chemical or hormonal imbalance. However, the simultaneous mutual interaction of all human system components—mind, body, spirit, and emotions—is required for sustainability of life and sustainability of dysfunction.

The disease model focuses on the history of deficit behavior. The American Psychiatric Association’s (APA) brief definition of neurosis contains the following words: distressing, irrational, obsessive, compulsive, dissociative, depressive, exaggerated, unconscious, and conflicts. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), published by the APA, uses words like incapable, deceitful, unempathetic, manipulative, difficult, irresponsible, and incompetent. 

Moralists and the ignorant assume the ‘mental’ are weak and dishonorable, their behavior bizarre and illogical. The urban dictionary labels us silly or stupid. Adolescents derisively assign the term mental to the unpopular, different, and socially inept. These negative and hostile aspersions on our character are supported by public opinion, media misrepresentation, the mental healthcare industry, and the disease model of mental health.

This ‘defective’ emphasis has been the overriding psychiatric perspective for over a century. The disease model is the chief proponent of the notion that the mentally ill are dangerous and unpredictable. We distance ourselves and deem them socially undesirable. We stigmatize them. The irony is, we are them.

  • Over one-third of family members hide their relationship with their dysfunctional child or sibling to avoid bringing shame to the family. They are considered family undesirable, a devaluation potentially more life-limiting and disabling than the neurosis itself.
  • The media stereotypes neurotics as homicidal schizophrenics, impassive childlike prodigies, or hair-brained free-spirits. One study evidenced that over half of U.S. news stories involving the dysfunctional allude to violence.
  • Psychologists argue that more persons would seek treatment if psychiatric services were less stigmatizing. There are complaints of rude or dismissive staff, coercive measures, excessive wait times, paternalistic or demeaning attitudes, pointless treatment programs, drugs with undesirable side-effects, stigmatizing language, and general therapeutic pessimism.
  • The disease model supports doctor-patient power dominance. Clinicians deal with 31 similar and comorbid disorders, 400 plus schools of psychotherapy, multiple treatment programs, and an evolving plethora of medications. They cannot grasp the personal impact of a dysfunction because they are too focused on the diagnosis.

A recent study of 289 clients in 67 clinics found that 76.4% were misdiagnosed. An anxiety clinic reported over 90% of clients with generalized anxiety were incorrectly diagnosed. Experts cite the difficulty in distinguishing different disorders or identifying specific etiological risk factors due to the DSM’s failing reliability statistics. Mainstream medical authorities cite the poor reliability and validity, and inattention to human experience of DSM criteria. The recent head of the National Institute of Mental Health believes traditional psychiatric diagnoses have outlived their usefulness and suggests replacing or augmenting them with easily understandable descriptions of the issues.

Because of the disease model’s emphasis on diagnosis, we focus on the dysfunction rather than the individual. Which disorder do we find most annoying or repulsive? What behaviors contribute to the condition? How progressive is it, and how effective are treatments? Is it contagious? We derisively label the obvious dysfunctional ‘a mental case.’

Realistically, we cannot eliminate the word ‘mental’ from the culture. Unfortunately, its negative perspectives and implications promulgate perceptions of incompetence, ineptitude, and unlovability. Stigma, the hostile expression of someone’s undesirability, is pervasive and destructive. Stigmatization is deliberate, proactive, and distinguishable by pathographic overtones intended to shame and isolate. 90% of persons diagnosed with a mental disorder claim they have been impacted by mental health stigma. Disclosure jeopardizes livelihoods, relationships, social standing, housing, and quality of life.

The disease model assumes that emotional distress is merely symptomatic of biological illness. The Wellness Model focuses on the positive aspects of human functioning that promote our wellbeing and recognize our essential and shared humanity. The Wellness Model emphasizes what is right with us, innately powerful within us, our potential, and determination. Recovery is not achieved by focusing on incompetence and weakness; it is achieved by embracing and utilizing our inherent strengths and abilities.

Benefits of the Wellness Model

  • Revising negative and hostile language will encourage new positive perspectives
  • The self-denigrating aspects of shame will dissipate, and stigma becomes less threatening.
  • Doctor-client knowledge exchange will value the individual experience over the diagnosis.
  • Realizing neurosis is a natural part of human development will generate social acceptance and accommodation.
  • Recognizing that they bear no responsibility for onset will revise public opinion that an individual’s neurosis is the result of her or his behavior.
  • Emphasizing character strengths and virtues will positively impact the self-beliefs and image of the afflicted, leading to more disclosure, discussion, and recovery-remission.
  • Realizing proximity and susceptibility of dysfunction will address the desire to distance and isolate.
  • Emphasis on an individual’s value and potential will encourage accountability and foster self-reliance.

The impact of neurosis originates in childhood; recovery is a long-term commitment. The Wellness Model creates the blueprint and then guides and supports throughout the recovery process by emphasizing our intrinsic character strengths, virtues, and attributes that generate the motivation, persistence, and perseverance to recover.

The biblical adage treat others as you want to be treated takes on added relevance when we accept that we all experience mental disorders. In fact, dysfunction is evidence of our humanness.

robertfmullen.com

Dr. Robert F. Mullen is the director of ReChanneling Inc, an organization dedicated to the research and development of methods to mitigate symptoms of psychological dysfunction and discomfort.

A referenced copy of this article is available via rechanneling@yahoo.com.

For more from Dr. Robert F. Mullen click here.


If you enjoyed this post don’t forget to like, follow, share and comment.
To submit a guest post email me on: insomniacwithanaccent@gmail.com

21 thoughts on “Dysfunction is Evidence of Our Humanness (Guest Post)

  1. The issue of mental health has been ignored to the fullest as nobody cares. I have seen people commit suicide as a result.
    Two of my high school friends are currently victims of mental health. One of them started exhibiting symptoms of some disorder at the time he was a bit closer to me. Most of us couldn’t understand the behaviour until he became violent to the extent he beat up his girlfriend to the point of hospitalization. He did this in full view of the public.
    Efforts to help him couldn’t be appreciated because even the mental hospital failed him. Maybe because of the same stigma by health workers.
    I wish we had a good education in this space. These friends of mine today are separated from society as their conditions have gotten worse.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. I agree there is definitely not enough awareness about mental health and people need to be educated about mental illnesses especially the more common ones so that when someone around us starts exhibiting signs we can help them out.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Wow! I feel so schooled. And I particularly like it because mental health is something not so many people care about. Just late last year, 3 student from my school committed suicide and depression was the perpetrator. Only then did people rise to think about mental health. The least you could do for someone is to not judge them. And always act with kindness because we have no idea what people are going through. Just be nice to people.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Yeah not enough people talk and care about mental health which is so sad because it’s so common. You’re so right- just because someone seems okay on the outside does not mean they are fine on the inside. Always respect others and treat them with kindness.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. There are assumptions made that are not entirely accurate. It seems that the assumption is made that there is mental illness in everyone, however the actual diagnoses is made because it is affecting the person’s ability to function in their daily life (work, home, school etc). Not everyone will be diagnosed and some who have mental illnesses will not be diagnosed Diagnoses or not is not the issue….discrimination is the issue and that is due to ignorance and lack of information.
    https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/what-is-mental-illness. It isn’t the medical or mental health groups that create the lack of tolerance. That is created by a society that does not understand clinical diagnosis nor understand that mental illness is treatable. Diagnoses are not made lightly. Everyone has different quirks and personality differences, this does not always translate into mental health disorder. https://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/sites/default/files/actions_speak__louder_0.pdf gives a different perspective on the discrimination that occurs. Remember there are always multiple considerations and mental illness or mental wellness is not actually something found funny in real clinicians. Hope this helps 🙂

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Sorry, forgot to add that mental health/mental wellness occurs on a continuum. Mental illness is only diagnosed when life (school, work, family) life is negatively impacted. Assuming that this is true, then if it is not affecting your life negatively, you could have a mental illness, however, since you are functioning in life, then you would not meet diagnostic criterion. However, the actual point is more that prejudices and discrimination occur because people just assume and don’t find out and they mistreat people based on mental health status…and that is inappropriate and discrimination. I had, for several years, until I became ill, worked to become a Psychologist. I can advise you that no one that I worked with joked about mental illness, depression, anxiety or other mental illnesses. We understood the seriousness of the disorders and we did not diagnose…as a College Counsellor, it was more a necessity to refer to Mental Health and make sure they got proper diagnoses and treatment. What we need to work on is not discrediting mental health/mental illness, but on treatment and information. Hope this helps 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

    2. Hello,
      Thank you for sharing your insight. I so agree. Further, that those who experience severe/ongoing mental health issues don’t joke about it – unless with people you are very comfortable with when it can be a release. This is the reason I cannot abide celebrities like Ruby Wax who say they’ve found their ‘tribe’ and then make money from pedalling homilies. Every MH condition is a continuum, just as every ND. I fall into bipolar 1, psychosis, complex attachment disorder, autism, sensory integration dysfunction. And just like every other individual on the planet I am unique. Medication, ECT, CBT, DBT – none have changed who I am. And I’m glad.
      Disability is the result, not of my inability to perform within society, but of society’s inability to accommodate my individuality. As a person I am able; society has disabled me.
      And that’s not funny.
      Thank you for your input.
      Thank you PoojaG for the post.
      All the best to everyone, Marilyn x

      Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s